Welcome to the positive corner of the internet. We’re here to make your life healthier, happier, and less stressful. At the bottom of each email, we explain our editorial process, stance on AI, and partnership standards. |
If you were forwarded this message, you can get the free daily email here. |
Today’s Health Upgrade |
Breaking down the colostrum claims The real cost of “cognitive labor” Are emulsifiers and preservatives dangerous? Adam’s Corner: Stop faking it
|
Not So Fast Colostrum’s Best Evidence Doesn’t Explain Its Popularity |
Editor’s Note: We were recently offered a very generous 6-figure partnership by a company selling colostrum. Like all partnerships, we started with the research, evidence-based outcomes, and conversations with the smartest people in the field. We value our partners. Many of you ask why we have ads, and the reasons are simple: 1) Partners allow us to send a free email 5 days per week and pay our employees and the hard costs of hosting a newsletter for over a million people. 2) There are genuinely good products and services we value and use ourselves. And if they can help you become better, we want you to know about them. |
At the same time, we turn down >90% of partnership requests. You can’t buy your way into being a Pump Club partner. You have to earn it. If a product or service doesn’t meet our standards, we won’t promote it, no matter how much money we could make. We turned down the colostrum partnership, and this breakdown will help you understand why. — |
A few years ago, you had to go looking for colostrum. Now it’s on a shelf at Target, and US sales have jumped from under $1 million a year to roughly $20 million. |
Despite the popularity, you might be paying a lot for a colostrum supplement that does little or offers nothing close to the benefits you’re sold. |
Colostrum is the first milk a cow makes after giving birth. It’s loaded with antibodies and growth factors built for a newborn calf. The pitch for adults is a magic pill of tantalizing promises: energy, gut health, immunity, muscle, and even better skin. |
The research behind those claims? Nowhere as impressive. |
Scientists reviewed five small trials of (mostly male) endurance athletes taking 10 to 20 grams of colostrum a day for 8 to 12 weeks. The hard-training athletes reported about 44% fewer days with cold-like symptoms. |
The key word is “reported.” None of the trials confirmed an infection with a lab test, and four of the five had a moderate-to-high risk of bias. From a research standpoint, that is not good. |
When researchers measured the immune system directly, colostrum barely made any difference. |
Add in that many of these trials were run by researchers with ties to colostrum companies, and the signal is real enough to notice but too soft to bank on. |
So then it helps to look at other research for the other claims, and — unfortunately — the positive studies show the same pattern that makes it easy to question the strength of the results. |
The gut-lining studies were underwhelming, and much of that work came from a group whose senior researcher later ran R&D at a colostrum company. |
When an independent team finally tested colostrum during heat stress, it found no benefit. |
The claims about muscle gain are also unfounded. |
About half a dozen small trials have tested colostrum alongside weight training, mostly against whey protein. None found colostrum built more muscle. |
And on strength claims, it consistently showed no advantage. |
And then there’s the dose. Most of these studies used around 60 grams a day, roughly three times a typical scoop. The growth factors everyone gets excited about don’t seem to reach your bloodstream in meaningful amounts, either. |
That doesn’t mean colostrum is dangerous. Based on the research, it’s generally safe, and some people get mild stomach upset. If you’re allergic to milk, then you’ll probably want to stay away. |
But for the cost of the supplement, you can likely do more for your health, performance, or happiness with other options. |
Together With Matic How Every Chore Costs You Twice (And Why A Handoff Is Helpful) |
You might measure your to-do list in minutes. Vacuuming takes 20. The grocery run takes an hour. Cross it off and move on. |
But that math skips the bigger bill. Before you do almost anything, you have to notice it needs doing, figure out how, decide when, and then keep checking that it actually happened. |
That thinking runs in the background all day, for dozens of tasks at once. Most of us never count it, but it drains you in ways you don’t realize. |
A Harvard sociology researcher interviewed couples and broke household tasks into exactly those pieces: anticipating the need, spotting options, deciding, and monitoring the result. She called it cognitive labor. |
Cognitive labor is often invisible, sometimes even to the person carrying it, and in her study it fell mostly on one partner (usually the woman). That person feels drained and can’t quite explain why, since none of it shows up on a chore chart. |
Here’s how it changes once you see it: Hand off a task completely, meaning the noticing, planning, and follow-up, not just the doing, and you get back more than 20 minutes. You get back the part of your brain that’s been on watch all day. |
You can’t outsource all of it, and you shouldn’t want to. No app will notice when someone in your life needs extra attention, and no service will remember your kid hates the itchy socks. That stuff deserves your personal touch |
Some tasks don’t, though. They refill every day and ask nothing of you except vigilance. Floors are the classic case: dog hair behind the couch, crumbs under the kids’ chairs, whatever got tracked in from the yard. Somebody is always half-watching them. |
Take those off your plate whenever possible. Handing one to your partner only works if they own the whole thing. If you’re still the one noticing and reminding, the watching never left your head. |
That rule applies to anything you hand off, including a robot. If you still have to clear the floor first, rescue it from under the couch and cut hair off the brush, you haven’t handed anything off. You’ve just started watching something new. |
That’s why Matic is one of our most useful recommendations: it takes the whole job of cleaning your home and does it so well that it earned WIRED’s only 10/10 review in 17 years of reviews. |
It maps your home with five cameras, goes around shoes and chair legs like a self-driving car, and switches between vacuuming and mopping on its own. It’s the ultimate cleaning tool, and nobody has to notice, plan, or follow up because there’s: |
Nothing to untangle. Angled fins push pet hair sideways instead of wrapping it around the brush. |
Nothing to empty. It wrings out its own mop and seals dust and dirty water in one HEPA-12 bag that captures 99.5% of particles down to 0.3 microns. |
Nothing to schedule around. At 55 dB, it’s quieter than a conversation, so it can run during dinner, nap time, or a work call. |
The Verge tested more than 80 robot vacuums and named it the best. Yes, it’s an investment. It also takes one whole category of watching off your plate for good. |
As a Pump Club reader, you can get $700 in total savings on the Matic Serene Bundle or $600 in total savings on the Matic Bundle; both offers include MaticCare ($180 value included free) and the Annual Bag Pass ($120 value). |
The offer is only good until December 1. And if you order by November 30, you’ll have it in time for Christmas. |
If you know who does the noticing in your house, then you already know who will appreciate the Matic the most. |
Nutrition Are Emulsifiers and Preservatives Hurting You? |
Ingredient labels have turned into a horror genre. Carrageenan, polysorbate-80 and sodium benzoate sound like things from a chemistry set, and that alone scares a lot of people. |
Despite the fear-based messaging, no human study has shown that the emulsifiers and preservatives in your food make healthy people sick. |
These additives had to pass a safety test to get into your food. Researchers feed animals large doses over long periods and find the highest amount that causes no harm. Then they set the limit for people about 100 times lower. (Some ingredients get to shelves through a looser “generally recognized as safe” route, which is a fair knock on the system.) |
That testing wasn’t built to catch one thing: subtle effects on gut bacteria. |
That gap is where the fear started. In a 2015 study, mice given two common emulsifiers in their drinking water developed gut inflammation and put on fat. That was mice, at doses far above anything on your plate. Later, a French survey of 105,000 adults linked some preservatives to slightly higher cancer rates. But a survey can’t separate the additive from the diet it comes in. |
Once researchers tested people directly, the alarm faded. Researchers have conducted three randomized trials in healthy adults. Cellulose gum lowered some protective gut compounds. Carrageenan nudged up gut permeability. The largest trial found no change in inflammation. |
Crohn’s is the exception. In a 154-person trial, 49% of people improved on a low-emulsifier diet, compared with 31% who didn’t avoid emulsifiers. |
So if you’re healthy and don’t have a gut condition (that should be directed by your physician), you can eat without panicking. If you’d still rather not take the chance, that’s your choice. Swap the packaged food you eat most days for one with a shorter ingredient list. If you have Crohn’s or another health condition, ask your GI team about a low-emulsifier diet they supervise. |
Adam’s Corner Stop Faking It |
“Yes! Yes! Yes!” |
I heard it through my headphones, which is an accomplishment in itself. I keep my music loud enough to build a wall around me (sorry, hearing!), especially on the road, when I’m training in a public gym instead of my basement. |
I tried to stay focused. But then it happened again. |
“Yes! Yes! Yes!” |
I’ve been coaching people for a quarter of a century. When you’ve watched that much training in that many gyms, you learn that a sound like that is usually a good reason not to look up. |
I looked up. |
A trainer was clapping on every rep as if he’d just watched a walk-off home run. I don’t mind a trainer who brings energy and tries to elevate their client. But there’s a difference between yelling for effect and yelling for appearance. |
In front of him, his client was working through a set of med ball slams, where everything was wrong. The ball didn’t go overhead. It was a full squat instead of an explosive downward movement meant to mimic a crunch. The back position was all wrong. You could argue that, aside from making a “slam!” noise and putting in the effort, nothing was done right. |
As fatigue built, each rep got a little worse. Each rep got a louder “yes.” |
It thought to myself, “Not your client. Not your gym.” |
I looked away and got back to my workout. |
Bad training isn’t rare. It’s one of the main reasons we built the Pump Club app, because there’s so much poor coaching and lazy programming out there that people deserve a better option. |
I can forgive bad form because almost everyone starts from that place. Most people are never taught. But bad coaching is something else. That trainer wasn’t just letting a mistake slide. He was applauding it. |
And to be fair, it’s not necessarily all negative. Maybe his client walked out feeling great. Maybe that feeling gets her back on Thursday, and maybe she stands a little taller at work. Those things matter. We call this newsletter the positive corner of the internet for a reason. |
Enthusiasm is contagious in the best way, and I’ve watched hope and belief carry people further than any program. |
But eventually, as the kids (and a lot of adults) like to say, the bills come due. |
One morning, that client might look in the mirror or step on the scale and not see results. Or maybe she’ll start feeling pain in her lower back, and wonder why the frequent “yes” treatment became an “oh no.” |
| ❝ | | | We assume passion comes first and fuels the work. But more often, the work creates lasting passion. |
|
|
The Deception of “It Works For Me” |
Earlier this week, I hosted my weekly live nutrition call in the app, and a member brought up our nutrition tracker. |
He wanted to use it. The problem was that it doesn’t count macros, and he’s a macro guy. Tracking his protein, carbs, and fats to the gram gives him a sense of control. |
I understand that. Our tracker takes a different approach. It asks for more honesty about what you’re actually eating and a lot less stress about grams and calories. It’s worked for tens of thousands of people, so we know it delivers. But it’s different, and different feels uncomfortable. |
“Counting macros works for me,” he said. |
“Great,” I told him. “All we want is your success.” |
Then I asked the only question that mattered. “What does ‘works for you’ mean?” |
“I feel like I’m doing it right.” |
“Are you seeing results?” |
“No.” |
“So is the goal to feel good about yourself,” I asked, “or to get results?” |
I wasn’t trying to corner him. The honest answer is both, and he deserves both. |
But wanting both doesn’t mean you’ll feel good every step of the way. |
A lot of the path to real results feels awkward and slow. The often the price of progress. |
And when you trade your results for comfort, you usually don’t get to keep the comfort either. |
You lose your confidence first, because some part of you knows the changes aren’t happening. Then your spark. Then your consistency, because it’s hard to keep showing up for something that keeps letting you down. Eventually it’s all of it. |
Enthusiasm without execution is a house of cards. It looks impressive right up until the first strong breeze. |
The “Yes” You Earn |
Execution is less exciting to talk about because it requires accountability, and accountability comes from two places. |
The external kind is a coach who tells you the truth instead of what you want to hear, or a tracker that won’t let you round down. |
The internal kind is harder. It’s being willing to ask yourself whether what “works” is actually working. |
If you lie to yourself with enthusiasm, all the hype in the world won’t get you where you want to go. |
We assume passion comes first and fuels the work. |
But more often, the work creates lasting passion. |
Researchers have a name for this. They call it the IKEA effect. When people built something with their own hands, even a simple storage box, they valued it more than an identical one that came pre-assembled. |
The effort didn’t just produce the box. It produced the attachment. |
Your body works the same way. The first pull-up you earned after months of negatives. The jeans that fit again after a year of boring, repeatable dinners. The promotion that came after years of working harder than anyone else. |
Nobody had to cheer for you to feel those. You felt them because you knew exactly what they cost. |
Passion isn’t always something you find. More often, you build it. And the harder the project, the greater the connection, achievement, and satisfaction. |
So take stock of the things you’re saying yes to. Ask what “working” would look like if it were working. A number, a lift, a feeling in your clothes, a blood test. Then be honest about whether you’re seeing it. |
Habits are supposed to become automatic. That’s how most progress gets made. But the longer you do something, the more it feels like it’s working, whether it’s moving you forward or not. |
That trainer’s “yes” was easy to catch. I heard it over my music. |
Listen for the yes in your own head. The one that tells you you’ve got this handled because you show up and you work hard. It sounds a lot like confidence. And sometimes it is. |
But sometimes it’s a distraction from what really matters. Just a loud noise and a ball hitting the floor. -AB |
-Adam Bornstein is the co-founder and co-editor-in-chief of Arnold’s Pump Club |
|
|
| | | | Take any of these tips from today’s email and put them into action: | 1. Does Colostrum Work? The Research Is Underwhelming | For most people, colostrum isn't worth it: its only consistent signal is fewer self-reported cold symptoms in hard-training endurance athletes, with 44% fewer symptom days across five small trials. And even that doesn’t prove it prevents illness. The claims about muscle building, gut health, and energy have little to no evidence to support them. | 2. Every Chore Costs You Twice: The Science of Cognitive Labor | The belief is that a chore takes as long as doing it. In fact, the planning and monitoring run all day, and nobody counts them. Cognitive labor is the invisible thinking behind household tasks (anticipating needs, identifying options, deciding and monitoring), and prior research on couples found it falls mostly on one partner (usually the woman). Finding ways to unload the task — as well as the cognitive labor — can improve well-being. | 3. Why Emulsifiers And Preservatives Are Safer Than People Make Them Seem | For healthy adults, human trials haven't shown that food emulsifiers or preservatives cause illness. The clearest effect is in Crohn's disease: in the ADDapt trial, 49% improved on a low-emulsifier diet compared with 31% who had emulsifiers added back. The belief is that chemical-sounding additives are quietly making everyone sick. However, the human trials in healthy people suggest there’s no reason to worry. | 4. Passion Doesn't Always Fuel the Work. The Work Can Build the Passion | Feeling like your routine is working doesn’t mean it is, so real progress starts with accountability: decide ahead of time what “working” looks like, such as a heavier lift, a smaller waist, or a better blood test, then be honest about whether it’s happening. Research on the IKEA effect found that people value something they built with their own hands more than an identical one that came already assembled. That’s the case for the slow, uncomfortable work: results you earn through honest, repeated effort are the ones you’ll care about most and keep the longest. |
| |
| |
| | |
|
The Positive Corner of The Internet About Arnold’s Pump Club Editorial Standards |
We do things a bit differently here, starting with transparency. |
The Content: All APC emails are researched, written, and fact-checked by the APC editors (see bottom of the email), with written contributions from Arnold (noted with “Arnold’s Corner”). Links take you to original studies (not second-hand sources). Does AI play a role? Not for the primary content, but we use it in two ways. The main items are original content written by the APC team. The summaries at the end are AI-generated based on the human-written content above. We also use an AI tool to edit and review our interpretations of the research, ensuring scientific accuracy. We don’t assume AI is right, but we use technology to hold ourselves accountable. Yes, we have partners (all clearly noted by “Together With”). Why? Because it allows us to keep the APC emails free. We first test products, and then reach out to potential partners who offer ways to help you improve every day. The bar is set high, and to date, we have turned down millions in ad deals. (Example: we will not partner with any non-certified supplements or those without evidence in human trials). If we won’t buy the product, we won’t recommend it to you. And if there’s no evidence it works, then there’s no place for it here.
|
— |
Publisher: Arnold Schwarzenegger |
Editors-in-chief: Adam Bornstein and Daniel Ketchell |