Screw the discounts.
We tried 40% off and it backfired.
Arnold Schwarzenegger <[email protected]>
Share
Arnold's Pump Club promotes a challenge where members can earn a free first year of the Pump Club app by completing 12 workouts before January 1 and finishing four programs within their first year. The company incentivizes members with a $50 refund for completing the initial 12 workouts. Arnold's Pump Club rejects traditional Black Friday discounts, instead focusing on motivating members to achieve their fitness goals.
What the raw message shows
From the headers
- Sent with
-
Beehiiv See it in the headers
Across Arnold's Pump Club's email
- Sends
- About 6 a week
- DMARC
-
Not enforced
Failures are monitored but still delivered.
The copy
576 words · about 2 min to read · 1 button
November 22, 2026
Why We’re Not Doing a Black Friday Discount
And why your first year of the Pump Club app can be free. It starts with doing 12 workouts before January 1. A letter from Ketch, our co-CEO.
Everybody is giving you 40, 50, 60% off right now.
Discounts work great for TVs. They don’t work for workouts. A discount gets you to buy. It doesn’t get you to show up. We know because we tried it, and our data was brutal (more on that in a minute).
So screw the discounts. We’d rather pay you back all your money to work out.
We want you to achieve your goals and get our fitness app for free. And that means incentivizing you to put in the work.
Do 12 workouts before January 1, and we’ll pay you $50 back. Automatically refunded to your card.
Finish four programs in your first year, and the app costs you nothing.
(It actually costs us money because of credit card processing fees.)
We’ve already paid back hundreds of thousands of dollars to members.
Button Join the Challenge →
You might be thinking: What the hell? Why not just give me the stupid $50 discount?
Here's the thing.
But I put “work” in quotation marks for a reason.
We ran 40% off for one of these sales, just like everybody else.
Sales skyrocketed. Workouts plummeted.
Which is kind of the whole fitness industry business model, right? Get you in January with a discount, knowing you'll quit by February. Profit.
Here's the part nobody in fitness says out loud: we make more money when you quit too. Every fitness company does. A member who never opens the app costs us almost nothing.
That's the fitness business. We just decided it isn't our business.
Our boss is Arnold, not investors
We don't answer to private equity or VCs.
We answer to Arnold Schwarzenegger, whose fitness crusade started before most of the investors behind other apps were born. Our boss says we're doing our job if people are training. He's willing to take a loss if it means people finally find fitness.
The fitness industry has never been bigger, and it has never failed more people.
So yes, we could give you 40% off like everybody else. It wouldn’t hurt our bottom line, because most people who download a fitness app are gone within a month, but they keep paying anyway.
But we don't sell failure.
What happens when you finish
We've watched what happens when people finish. Members who complete a program renew 76% of the time. Members who start one and don't finish renew 27% of the time.
One program (about three months) turns skeptics into believers.
And it starts earlier than we thought. Get through your first 12 workouts, and you're three times more likely to finish your program than quit.
That's where this challenge comes from.
How the challenge works
Step 1: Join Pump Club on our website before December 1. The first 7 days are free, and then it’s $150 a year.
Step 2: Do 12 workouts by January 1, and we pay you $50. You don’t have to request anything. You’ll just see the money back on your card.
Step 3: Finish your first program — about 12 weeks of consistently working out. Another $50 back.
(Yes, that means that, by the time everybody else is quitting their resolutions, you’ve built a habit and already earned back $100.)
The words as text: what a screen reader can follow, and all there is when images don't load.
What the headers say
Read from the message's own headers, as it arrived.
- Came from
-
o215.ptr4268.schwarzenegger.com
· 149.72.150.178
Beehiiv's sending servers
- SPF
- Pass for em2589.schwarzenegger.com
- DKIM
-
- Pass signed by schwarzenegger.com
- DMARC
-
Pass for schwarzenegger.com
Policy: none, so failures would still be delivered
- Unsubscribe
-
One-click
Meets the Gmail and Yahoo rule for bulk senders.
- Complaints
-
Feedback loop set up
Mailbox providers can report spam complaints straight back to the sender.
Show all 26 headers Hide the headers
As received, minus the delivery side: the archive's own addresses show as [recipient], its mail servers as [receiver], signatures are left out and unsubscribe links trimmed to their host.
Route
- Received
- from o215.ptr4268.schwarzenegger.com (149.72.150.178) by [receiver] (cloudflare) id 17IvPpfOVONz for <[recipient]>; Sun, 22 Nov 2026 14:56:45 +0000
- Received
- by recvd-6878cc76bc-j8gw6 with SMTP id recvd-6878cc76bc-j8gw6-1-6B0302A7-26 2026-11-22 14:56:39.152892635 +0000 UTC m=+1002324.215449427
- Received
- from MzM1OTE2ODY (unknown) by geopod-ismtpd-73 (SG) with HTTP id wKMSG-rNS3qPDDca62rpiA Sun, 22 Nov 2026 14:56:39.111 +0000 (UTC)
Authentication
- Received-SPF Authentication result
- pass ([receiver]: domain of bounces+33591686-6253-pumpclubinboxarchive.org@em2589.schwarzenegger.com designates 149.72.150.178 as permitted sender) receiver=[receiver]; client-ip=149.72.150.178; envelope-from="[recipient]@em2589.schwarzenegger.com"; helo=o215.ptr4268.schwarzenegger.com;
- Authentication-Results Authentication result
- [receiver]; dkim=pass header.d=schwarzenegger.com header.s=5b7 header.b=L68iSCIL; dmarc=pass header.from=schwarzenegger.com policy.dmarc=none; spf=none ([receiver]: no SPF records found for [email protected]) smtp.helo=o215.ptr4268.schwarzenegger.com; spf=pass ([receiver]: domain of bounces+33591686-6253-pumpclubinboxarchive.org@em2589.schwarzenegger.com designates 149.72.150.178 as permitted sender) smtp.mailfrom="[recipient]@em2589.schwarzenegger.com"; arc=none smtp.remote-ip=149.72.150.178
Platform
- x-beehiiv-ids Identifies Beehiiv
- {"account_name":"https://arnoldspumpclub.schwarzenegger.com/","campaign_id":"37e2e625-a21c-4a28-bf69-433d7c2f662a","category":"newsletter","email_generated_at":1795359398,"user_id":"69cc9605-b59a-4e5a-a91e-91120246acec"}
- x-beehiiv-type Identifies Beehiiv
- newsletter
- x-list-id
- 69cc9605-b59a-4e5a-a91e-91120246acec
- x-list-owner
- <mailto:[email protected]>
- x-newsletter
- https://arnoldspumpclub.schwarzenegger.com/p/why-we-re-not-doing-a-black-friday-discount
- x-newsletter-id
- https://arnoldspumpclub.schwarzenegger.com/
- x-newsletter-signup
- https://arnoldspumpclub.schwarzenegger.com/subscribe
- X-SG-EID
- u001.kVOnjYVX26cmN5P1FyRANU9qxnDjz4plGa1J/M0FL/Fs13BqdjiGaGncoCTugHsMJjhn4QeO3SXBMs6NftogIQlE7DJWKnY34usJ7ePPpfC+TdgUtIwPAse0tKZP+fKw3AA1JX4CB4Ql7pRdSOBZb5PHukLy1fJErONNv0umCY3TSWfLo+ZPAbNiTYiN9fjJuCtxaRAX80PoTVPiFq3JMCdYzNF9FFDIWctez15QeHnUb17MPW8/rbqcIVHwp4mkdnoav5t4U8OXAagfC0U6Fg==
- X-SG-ID
- u001.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
- X-Entity-ID
- u001.YYUjHoyTMCS5hdY+xrwXDg==
Unsubscribe and feedback
- Feedback-ID
- 37e2e625-a21c-4a28-bf69-433d7c2f662a:newsletter:69cc9605-b59a-4e5a-a91e-91120246acec:c30e8088a6065bb
- List-Unsubscribe
- <mailto:…@unsub.beehiiv.com>, <https://arnoldspumpclub.schwarzenegger.com/…>
- List-Unsubscribe-Post
- List-Unsubscribe=One-Click
Message
- Content-Type
- multipart/alternative; boundary=7d8515bf54030996d7af36b38d17d2452a31b89e8634a1842cf92ad682c6
- Date
- Sun, 22 Nov 2026 14:56:45 +0000 (UTC)
- From
- Arnold Schwarzenegger <[email protected]>
- Mime-Version
- 1.0
- Message-ID
- <wKMSG-rNS3qPDDca62rpiA@geopod-ismtpd-73>
- Subject
- Screw the discounts.
- Reply-To
- Arnold Schwarzenegger <[email protected]>
- sId
- 69cc9605-b59a-4e5a-a91e-91120246acec
More from Arnold's Pump Club
All 67 emailsSimilar campaigns from other brands
Different brands running the same play. Compare any of them side by side.
Archived for reference and commentary. Arnold's Pump Club, its logos and content are the property of their respective owners; Inbox Archive claims no affiliation and has disabled all links. If you own this content and would like it removed, get in touch.