Skip to content

the $20M supplement (and why we said no)

Welcome to the positive corner of the internet

Arnold Schwarzenegger <[email protected]>

Welcome & Onboarding

Share
Sent with Beehiiv Sends about 6 a week All facts

Arnold's Pump Club promotes a healthier lifestyle and shares research on colostrum supplements. They recently turned down a $20 million partnership with a colostrum company due to lack of evidence-based outcomes. The brand prioritizes earning partnerships over buying their way in, valuing quality products and services.

What the raw message shows

From the headers

Sent with
Beehiiv See it in the headers

Across Arnold's Pump Club's email

Sends
About 6 a week
DMARC
Not enforced

Failures are monitored but still delivered.

The copy

583 words · about 2 min to read

Colostrum's Best Evidence Doesn't Explain Its Popularity

Colostrum sales jumped 30-fold in two years. The best trials found fewer self-reported cold days. But most of the claims have little or no backing.

Welcome to the positive corner of the internet. We’re here to make your life healthier, happier, and less stressful. At the bottom of each email, we explain our editorial process, stance on AI, and partnership standards.

If you were forwarded this message, you can get the free daily email here.

Today’s Health Upgrade

Breaking down the colostrum claims

The real cost of “cognitive labor”

Are emulsifiers and preservatives dangerous?

Adam’s Corner: Stop faking it

Not So Fast

Editor’s Note: We were recently offered a very generous 6-figure partnership by a company selling colostrum. Like all partnerships, we started with the research, evidence-based outcomes, and conversations with the smartest people in the field. We value our partners. Many of you ask why we have ads, and the reasons are simple: 1) Partners allow us to send a free email 5 days per week and pay our employees and the hard costs of hosting a newsletter for over a million people. 2) There are genuinely good products and services we value and use ourselves. And if they can help you become better, we want you to know about them.

At the same time, we turn down >90% of partnership requests. You can’t buy your way into being a Pump Club partner. You have to earn it. If a product or service doesn’t meet our standards, we won’t promote it, no matter how much money we could make. We turned down the colostrum partnership, and this breakdown will help you understand why.

A few years ago, you had to go looking for colostrum. Now it’s on a shelf at Target, and US sales have jumped from under $1 million a year to roughly $20 million.

Despite the popularity, you might be paying a lot for a colostrum supplement that does little or offers nothing close to the benefits you’re sold. 

Colostrum is the first milk a cow makes after giving birth. It’s loaded with antibodies and growth factors built for a newborn calf. The pitch for adults is a magic pill of tantalizing promises: energy, gut health, immunity, muscle, and even better skin.

The research behind those claims? Nowhere as impressive.

Scientists reviewed five small trials of (mostly male) endurance athletes taking 10 to 20 grams of colostrum a day for 8 to 12 weeks. The hard-training athletes reported about 44% fewer days with cold-like symptoms.

The key word is “reported.” None of the trials confirmed an infection with a lab test, and four of the five had a moderate-to-high risk of bias. From a research standpoint, that is not good.

When researchers measured the immune system directly, colostrum barely made any difference. 

Add in that many of these trials were run by researchers with ties to colostrum companies, and the signal is real enough to notice but too soft to bank on.

So then it helps to look at other research for the other claims, and — unfortunately — the positive studies show the same pattern that makes it easy to question the strength of the results.

The gut-lining studies were underwhelming, and much of that work came from a group whose senior researcher later ran R&D at a colostrum company. 

When an independent team finally tested colostrum during heat stress, it found no benefit.

The claims about muscle gain are also unfounded. 

The words as text: what a screen reader can follow, and all there is when images don't load.

What the headers say

Read from the message's own headers, as it arrived.

Came from
o52.ptr8166.schwarzenegger.com · 159.183.134.120

Beehiiv's sending servers

SPF
Pass for em2589.schwarzenegger.com
DKIM
  • Pass signed by schwarzenegger.com
DMARC
Pass for schwarzenegger.com

Policy: none, so failures would still be delivered

Unsubscribe
One-click

Meets the Gmail and Yahoo rule for bulk senders.

Complaints
Feedback loop set up

Mailbox providers can report spam complaints straight back to the sender.

Show all 26 headers

As received, minus the delivery side: the archive's own addresses show as [recipient], its mail servers as [receiver], signatures are left out and unsubscribe links trimmed to their host.

Route

Received
from o52.ptr8166.schwarzenegger.com (159.183.134.120) by [receiver] (cloudflare) id yNPkP6du2oCL for <[recipient]>; Thu, 19 Nov 2026 11:03:47 +0000
Received
by recvd-d487cd69d-8x59t with SMTP id recvd-d487cd69d-8x59t-1-6AFED78B-6 2026-11-19 11:03:38.962399526 +0000 UTC m=+722430.255105728
Received
from MzM1OTE2ODY (unknown) by geopod-ismtpd-97 (SG) with HTTP id quZ0wB9OR0KuW9GJsfJaXw Thu, 19 Nov 2026 11:03:38.917 +0000 (UTC)

Authentication

Received-SPF Authentication result
pass ([receiver]: domain of bounces+33591686-6253-pumpclubinboxarchive.org@em2589.schwarzenegger.com designates 159.183.134.120 as permitted sender) receiver=[receiver]; client-ip=159.183.134.120; envelope-from="[recipient]@em2589.schwarzenegger.com"; helo=o52.ptr8166.schwarzenegger.com;
Authentication-Results Authentication result
[receiver]; dkim=pass header.d=schwarzenegger.com header.s=5b7 header.b=HpVn5lHe; dmarc=pass header.from=schwarzenegger.com policy.dmarc=none; spf=none ([receiver]: no SPF records found for [email protected]) smtp.helo=o52.ptr8166.schwarzenegger.com; spf=pass ([receiver]: domain of bounces+33591686-6253-pumpclubinboxarchive.org@em2589.schwarzenegger.com designates 159.183.134.120 as permitted sender) smtp.mailfrom="[recipient]@em2589.schwarzenegger.com"; arc=none smtp.remote-ip=159.183.134.120

Platform

x-beehiiv-ids Identifies Beehiiv
{"account_name":"https://arnoldspumpclub.schwarzenegger.com/","campaign_id":"f21f07b9-7f3f-49b2-a430-3f5d16f14360","category":"newsletter","email_generated_at":1795086218,"user_id":"69cc9605-b59a-4e5a-a91e-91120246acec"}
x-beehiiv-type Identifies Beehiiv
newsletter
x-list-id
69cc9605-b59a-4e5a-a91e-91120246acec
x-list-owner
<mailto:[email protected]>
x-newsletter
https://arnoldspumpclub.schwarzenegger.com/p/colostrum-supplement-evidence-review
x-newsletter-id
https://arnoldspumpclub.schwarzenegger.com/
x-newsletter-signup
https://arnoldspumpclub.schwarzenegger.com/subscribe
X-SG-EID
u001.kVOnjYVX26cmN5P1FyRANU9qxnDjz4plGa1J/M0FL/Fs13BqdjiGaGncoCTugHsMJjhn4QeO3SXBMs6NftogIQlE7DJWKnY34usJ7ePPpfBH6qZ3OVw9/BMVUKv6PH2b5WqEgVJr/aF/Br+w6qDupfWkubPSCGhilE0btnSZ5bdm3dS/SwCJ2WJE/c8eMuPDQCSdKVT+hf9McAqdBdiW5s8BdlLwi+/ismkJig44Zyhx1xHdC6cFj4Yn3ya9vK9ooAjAabRREWsEWrR3HxWnEg==
X-SG-ID
u001.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
X-Entity-ID
u001.YYUjHoyTMCS5hdY+xrwXDg==

Unsubscribe and feedback

Feedback-ID
f21f07b9-7f3f-49b2-a430-3f5d16f14360:newsletter:69cc9605-b59a-4e5a-a91e-91120246acec:c30e8088a6065bb
List-Unsubscribe
<mailto:…@unsub.beehiiv.com>, <https://arnoldspumpclub.schwarzenegger.com/…>
List-Unsubscribe-Post
List-Unsubscribe=One-Click

Message

Content-Type
multipart/alternative; boundary=339ced7c6b628fcab3e65fa84ee4b1435a7431982d7f7cf376205202e14a
Date
Thu, 19 Nov 2026 11:03:46 +0000 (UTC)
From
Arnold Schwarzenegger <[email protected]>
Mime-Version
1.0
Message-ID
<quZ0wB9OR0KuW9GJsfJaXw@geopod-ismtpd-97>
Subject
the $20M supplement (and why we said no)
Reply-To
Arnold Schwarzenegger <[email protected]>
sId
69cc9605-b59a-4e5a-a91e-91120246acec

More from Arnold's Pump Club

All 67 emails
Arnold's Pump Club

Screw the discounts.

Arnold's Pump Club

Are you training in the wrong shoes?

Arnold's Pump Club

How red wine lost its reputation

Arnold's Pump Club

Monday Motivation: The Service Solution

Similar campaigns from other brands

Different brands running the same play. Compare any of them side by side.

Gruns

The Proof Is in the Gummy Bear (And the Extensive Study We Did)

Compare
Organised

Cut out £200 worth of supplements with this.

Compare
I · M · 8

Final 24 hours.

Compare
TheFeed.

This weeks top 5: Labor Day = 26% Feed Cash on almost everything

Compare

Archived for reference and commentary. Arnold's Pump Club, its logos and content are the property of their respective owners; Inbox Archive claims no affiliation and has disabled all links. If you own this content and would like it removed, get in touch.